The Money Coach
  • About
    • Meet Lynnette
    • Media Kit
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • QR Code
  • Books
  • Categories
  • Coaching
  • Hire Lynnette
  • Money Coach University™
  • The Money Coach Recommends™
No Result
View All Result
The Money Coach
  • About
    • Meet Lynnette
    • Media Kit
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • QR Code
No Result
View All Result
The Money Coach
No Result
View All Result

Is The Credit Score Industry Fair to Consumers?

Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach by Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach
in Credit Scores
Reading Time: 4 mins read
Credit industry
7
SHARES
119
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

In my latest book, Perfect Credit, I explained that the credit score industry prefers to work together—without you whenever possible.

I’m not saying that they have no need for you or that they don’t want to have some dealings with you. After all, consumers provide valuable feedback and constitute a revenue source. And companies in the credit industry realize that, if they don’t address the consumer, their competitors will.

All in all, however, many folks in the credit industry would be quite happy if you just went away and not made any fuss about your credit.

Why do I say that the industry sometimes considers you a thorn in its side?

First of all, you have to realize that credit-scoring firms had to be dragged into having any direct interaction with consumers. The credit industry only started giving consumers a peek at their credit scores in 2001, despite the fact that the first commercial credit scores were created by the founders of Fair Isaac more than 50 years ago in 1958.

It wasn’t until the 1970s, however, when credit-card usage grew tremendously, that banks began widespread use of credit scores to reduce card delinquencies.

A couple decades later, in 1989, Fair Isaac released the first general-purpose credit score used to predict a consumer’s overall riskiness to a lender.  It was only at that point that any serious consideration was given to educating the consumer about credit scores.

Until then credit-scoring firms like Fair Isaac, as well as the credit bureaus themselves, had mainly focused all their attention on lenders and businesses that needed to obtain credit information in order to manage risk.

They were playing together nicely, thank you very much, until consumers and consumer advocates started demanding to know the exact same information to which lenders were privy.

VantageScore Brings More Competition to the FICO Score

More recently, credit industry players have shown other examples of how they can work together even as they compete with one another. In 2006, the “Big Three” credit bureaus – Equifax, Experian and TransUnion jointly developed their own credit score called the VantageScore.

Doing so raised the ire of Fair Isaac, which sued and alleged anti-trust violations. Fair Isaac, which makes the FICO score, lost that lawsuit and the VantageScore is still being marketed – as it should be.

Frankly, I don’t have a big problem with the credit bureaus getting together. The point of their creating a joint score was to minimize variation in people’s credit scores. You see, credit scores are based on the underlying information contained in each of your credit files. Thus, if Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion have different data about you, naturally your scores based on those three reports will vary. This is often exactly what people find.

In getting together, the Big Three tried to come up with a statistical model to lessen variation among the bureaus. So all in all, I don’t fault their efforts, but I do use it to point out that the bureaus, while competitors, are willing to work together.

The primary point of contact they have with you as an individual comes when you order a credit report, purchase a product, or dispute a mistake in your file.

Disputing Information in Your Credit Report

In the last scenario you have to fill out a dispute-resolution form, online or in the mail. And once you dispute something, what do the credit bureaus do next? Do they come back to you and ask you to prove what you said or to verify it independently? No, they really don’t.

They may allow you to send in supporting documentation to bolster your claims, but essentially the bureaus go to your creditors as the ultimate arbiters of the truth.

They basically go to the lenders, banks, collection agencies, or whatever entities reported you, and the credit bureaus say, “This individual disputes the information you provided. Do you agree or disagree?” (I’m summarizing, of course, but this is the gist of what happens). And based on what that lender or creditor or bill collector says, their response determines what goes into your credit report.

Either a creditor confirms the information, and it stays on your report, or the creditor can’t verify what was initially reported, and the information is dropped from your file. That’s a lot of power for the creditor to hold. And I have to question whether creditors are right 100% of the time. That doesn’t seem fair, logical or even remotely possible.

Nevertheless, what they say goes. This is standard operating procedure. The dispute-resolution process is legal, and it’s yet another example of how the entire industry works together, maximizing the flow of information among themselves and minimizing interactions with consumers. Perhaps that’s why less than 1% of credit report disputes are changed.

So if you ever feel that you’re not exactly receiving full disclosure about some aspect of your credit report or scores, just remember that the system was designed that way. The credit industry (not all players, but certainly many) wants to maintain control over and access to credit information for risk-management and profit motives.

They don’t want you to have the same insights and information that they do, nor do they want you to quash their creative maneuvering.

As one blogger wryly noted about the credit industry, specifically bank creditors and credit-scoring firms, “You have to admire their resourcefulness. Step 1: Cancel credit card because you don’t use it enough. Step 2: Lower your credit score because you had a credit card cancelled (or limit lowered). Step 3: Send dozens of offers through the mail for new credit cards with higher rates and fees. Repeat as often as needed.”

Again, in fairness to the credit industry, I don’t want to paint all the players with one broad brush. Clearly some exceptions to the rule exist.

Indeed, a select number of companies are bolstering their efforts to provide credit education for consumers, as opposed to just selling the public loan products, credit reports, credit scores, and credit-related services.

Overall, though, I believe that the industry can do a much better job of communicating with consumers, advocating financial literacy, and giving the public more insight into the complex world of credit management and credit scoring.

Tags: ConsumersCredit ratingPerfect Credit: 7 Steps to a Great Credit Rating
Previous Post

5 Tips to Save on Thanksgiving Travel

Next Post

How to Make a Budget Work after a Financial Downfall

Related Posts

credit score drops

What to Do If Your Credit Score Suddenly Drops Unexpectedly

by Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach

Need a quick refresher about how your credit score works? Due to inflation, many consumers are being forced to rely on their credit cards to make ends meet. As a result, many consumers have seen their credit scores go down as their balances go up. Here are 3 articles that...

rent payments to boost credit score

How to Use Rent Payments to Boost Your Credit Score

by Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach

This post originally appeared on Sisters from AARPBlack folks often face a host of credit challenges stemming from lower incomes, discrimination, a lack of knowledge about credit scoring and more. But one additional factor — the low rate of Black homeownership in America — has also meant diminished credit scores....

protect your credit score

How to Protect Your Credit Score After Job Loss 

by Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach

A lack of income makes it hard to cover your expenses, which can cause your credit score to fall. But there are ways to preserve it, even if you are out of work. Here are four tips for maintaining your credit score if you have lost your job.

Best Way to Check Your Credit Score Using Apps

The Best Way to Check Your Credit Score Using These 4 Apps

by Guest Blogger

Did you know that on a $21,788 auto loan, if you have an excellent credit score (740 – 749), you can pay 311% less in interest compared to an individual with a fair credit score (580 – 669)? 311% less! Your credit score determines whether you qualify for things like...

DTI Explained

DTI or Debt-to-Income Ratio Explained w/Video

by Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach

If you’re in the market for a loan, chances are that lenders are going to assess something called your “DTI” – also known as your Debt-to-Income ratio. What Exactly is a DTI? And, how can you improve it in order to get that loan that you want? How DTI is...

4 Summertime Risks to Your Credit Score

by Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach

Just because summertime is here and you might be taking it easy, that doesn’t mean you should let your guard down when it comes to your finances. In fact, during the summer season, you should be aware of a number of potential threats that can hurt your credit rating. Some...

credit score drop

What to Do If Your Credit Score Drops Unexpectedly

by Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach

  Having your credit score fall unexpectedly can be as bad as losing a significant amount of money. With a lower score, your opportunities for low-interest loans, lower insurance premiums, and more affordable mortgages may be out of your reach. What’s worse is that these fluctuations may come from out...

Load More

Popular Posts

  • Car repair

    What to Do If You Can’t Afford a Car Repair Bill

    1376 shares
    Share 550 Tweet 344
  • What to Do if Your Spouse Stole Money From You

    1165 shares
    Share 466 Tweet 291
  • What to Do If You Can’t Afford to Leave Your Spouse

    1102 shares
    Share 441 Tweet 276
  • Here’s Why I Pay My Kids For Good Grades (And Maybe You Should Too)

    1008 shares
    Share 403 Tweet 252
  • What Do All Those Strange Codes In My Credit Report Mean?

    813 shares
    Share 325 Tweet 203
  • Do This Now If Your Wages Were Not Reported

    743 shares
    Share 297 Tweet 186
  • How to Find Out if a Debt Collector is Licensed to Collect Your Debt

    722 shares
    Share 289 Tweet 181

All information on this blog is for educational purposes only. Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach, is not a certified financial planner, registered investment adviser, or attorney. If you need specialty financial, investment or legal advice, please consult the appropriate professional. Advertising Disclosure: This site may accept advertising, affiliate payments or other forms of compensation from companies mentioned in articles. This compensation may impact how and where products and companies appear on this site. AskTheMoneyCoach™ and Lynnette Khalfani-Cox, The Money Coach® are trademarks of TheMoneyCoach.net, LLC.

©2009-2023 TheMoneyCoach.net, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

RSS / Sitemap /Submit an Article / Privacy Policy / LynnetteKhalfaniCox.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Books
  • Categories
  • Contact Lynnette
  • Get Coaching
  • Hire Lynnette
  • Money Coach University™
  • The Money Coach Recommends™
  • Home
  • Subscribe to Newsletter
  • QR Code

©2009-2021 TheMoneyCoach.net, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist